Protein is one of the essential building blocks of the human body, crucial for building and repairing muscle. If you’re interested in gaining muscle and/or shedding fat, you likely know how important it is to boost your daily intake of this macronutrient. But is there an upper limit to how much you should consume? How much protein is considered too much?
There are goalposts, but it’s hard to go overboard. Here’s what the experts say.
Are High-Protein Diets Safe? First of all, it’s very difficult to eat so much protein that it negatively impacts your health. According to a study published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, the average American consumes less than half of what is widely considered the “upper bound” of protein consumption: 35 percent of daily calories.
However, studies suggest that active people exceeding that upper bound still may not see any adverse effects. In a 2016 study published in the Journal of Nutrition and Metabolism, 14 healthy, resistance-trained men alternated between months of consuming their normal diet and a “high-protein diet” (more than 3 grams per kilogram of bodyweight daily). To put that into context, a 154-pound person would have to eat more than 210 grams of protein per day on this diet, which is equivalent to almost two pounds of chicken.
After a year of monitoring the subjects, researchers found “no harmful effects on measures of blood lipids as well as liver and kidney function,” which is where most adverse responses to protein would appear.
Additionally, there is research suggesting that existing recommendations may be too low for certain populations, including adults over the age of 65, pregnant and lactating women, and healthy children older than 3 years. So while the scientific discourse around how much protein is too much continues, it’s important to acknowledge the emerging literature that validates the safety and efficacy of high-protein diets for those who require more of it.
3 Effects Associated With High-Protein Diets
While studies have explored potential risks of too much protein, the Dietary Reference Intakes by the Institute of Medicine asserts that there is “insufficient data” to provide causal relationships between protein and health complications, thus highlighting the need for controlled clinical studies.
1. Stomach upset/discomfort Some people may experience gastrointestinal issues resulting from protein supplementation. This may be attributable to the lactose content in certain protein shakes, such as those containing whey protein concentrate. In these cases, using whey protein isolate or plant-based protein is less likely to lead to these problems, as they contain less lactose than whey protein concentrate or none at all.
Potential GI issues can come from whole foods as well. “If you’re eating too much animal-based protein and not enough complex carbohydrates, which contain fiber, you may experience mild constipation,” explains Quyen Vu, MS, RDN.
2. Kidney issues Some studies have reported an association between high-protein diets and kidney function. However, it is “extremely rare” for exercisers to develop kidney issues or other metabolic disorders because of high protein consumption, says Glenn Gaesser, PhD, FACSM, professor of exercise physiology at Arizona State University.
3. Heart issues Some research suggests that eating excessive protein may affect the cardiovascular system.
“Several population-based cohort studies indicate a higher premature mortality risk associated with diets that are high in protein, such as the classic low-carb diet, which has much more protein than the typical American diet,” says Gaesser.
However, he continues, “The higher protein intake, per se, may not be the problem, but rather the other characteristics of the diet, such as high amounts of animal fat and low amounts of fiber-rich foods.”
Can Eating Too Much Protein Affect Weight Loss?
In a word, yes. Protein is a source of calories. If your goal is to lose weight, it’s important to create a calorie deficit, a state in which you’re burning more calories than you’re taking in. If you’re eating so much protein that it narrows (or erases) your calorie deficit, that can undermine weight loss.
“Protein not used for the body’s usual growth and maintenance functions may be used for energy, if there is a lack from other sources, and can be converted to fat,” says Mindy Haar, Ph.D., RDN, CDN, FAND, a registered dietitian nutritionist and assistant dean at New York Institute of Technology’s School of Health Professions. “If overconsuming protein leads you to consume more calories than you need, you will gain weight.”
However, protein is still an integral part of most weight loss efforts. A meta-analysis of 24 studies found that calorie-restricted, high-protein diets produced more positive changes to overall body composition than a standard-protein diet. This is likely because protein promotes fullness and can help preserve muscle.
How Do You Know if You’re Eating Too Much Protein? Your first clue will probably be a stomachache or some other minor gastrointestinal drama. Even if you have guts of steel, know that it’s possible to eat more protein than you can efficiently process.
“Your body can only utilize a certain amount of protein at one sitting — roughly 30 grams,” says Lisa Moskovitz, RD, CDN, CEO of New York Nutrition Group. “This is equivalent to about four ounces of cooked chicken breast or cooked fish, one cup of Greek yogurt, or two cups of black beans.”
It’s also important to space protein intake throughout the day because bodies don’t store excess protein.
“I see a lot in my practice that athletes try to pack in their protein intake in one or a couple of meals,” says Maddi Osburn, RDN, LD, a registered dietitian nutritionist in Wichita, Kansas. “If an athlete overconsumes protein in one or two meals, they won’t be getting the most optimal muscle growth response, and it will be either excreted or stored as fat. In addition, eating too much protein could displace other important nutrients — like carbohydrates, fat, and fiber — that are just as important for optimal recovery and performance.”
